Skip to main content
Law

PSSI Appeals Committee Overturns Sanctions Against PSIM Striker Mauro Caballero

PSSI's Appeals Committee has overturned PSIM Yogyakarta striker Mauro Caballero's 10-match ban and Rp350 million fine over alleged racist remarks, citing insufficient evidence.

Redaksi Kanal Politik3 min read
Ilustrasi berita: Komite Banding PSSI Anulir Sanksi terhadap Mauro Caballero
Ilustrasi berita: Komite Banding PSSI Anulir Sanksi terhadap Mauro Caballero

On 9 November 2026, the Football Association of Indonesia (PSSI) Appeals Committee granted PSIM Yogyakarta's appeal against sanctions imposed on striker Mauro Caballero, according to a report by the state news agency ANTARA from Jakarta.

Decision No. 005/KEP/KB/BRI-SUPERLEAGUE/XI/2026 overturned sanctions issued by PSSI's Disciplinary Committee (Komdis) on 27 October 2026: a 10-match playing ban, a one-time stadium ban and a fine of Rp350 million (about US$21,000). The sanctions were imposed over alleged racist remarks directed at a Bhayangkara Presisi Lampung FC player on 20 October 2026. The Appeals Committee found the evidence insufficient because the match commissioner's report and a video assistant referee (VAR) review showed the referee did not clearly hear the alleged words, under Article 97, paragraph 1, of the PSSI 2025 Disciplinary Code. Caballero will be eligible to play when PSIM face Persik Kediri on matchday 10 of the BRI Super League, Indonesia's top-flight football league sponsored by Bank Rakyat Indonesia (BRI), on 21 November 2026. “I did not commit any discriminatory act,” Caballero said. PSIM manager Iksan Mahar said the ruling upheld mutual respect.

Appeals process in football discipline

In Indonesian football, disciplinary sanctions usually arise through two channels: a referee's decision or an official match report, which are then assessed by the Disciplinary Committee. Because such decisions can affect players' careers and teams' results, the regulations provide an appeal mechanism. The Appeals Committee reviews whether the evidence, procedures and the sanction imposed were appropriate. This mechanism matters so that a judgment does not stop at one desk but can be tested by a different panel. In many countries, appeals of this kind also distinguish swift administrative sanctions from measured justice.

Discriminatory issues occupy a special place in football governance. World governing body FIFA, continental confederations and national federations promote zero tolerance for racism, but enforcement still requires valid evidence. In cases involving words, the main challenge is certainty: whether the words were truly heard, whether the context was clear, and whether witnesses or match officials can verify them. The match commissioner's report is an important document because the commissioner monitors the course of play and records offences that may not be directly visible.

Video reviews such as VAR do not automatically change conclusions. VAR helps show events on the pitch, but for alleged racist remarks, images alone are often not enough without clear audio evidence. The on-field referee, video officials and the match commissioner may have different perspectives. Open clarification can curb wild speculation. Therefore, provisions on evidentiary standards in the Disciplinary Code are decisive: sanctions must rest on sufficient evidence, not merely on suspicion.

For clubs, the appeal process is also a governance test. Management needs to prepare a chronology, evidence and a public narrative that does not pass judgment. Supporters and the public, meanwhile, should distinguish between allegations under review and final decisions. This principle helps ensure that anti-racism campaigns do not turn into verdicts without due process, while alleged victims of discrimination remain protected.

What the ruling means for competition and supporters

For Indonesian readers, the ruling is relevant because it touches two frequently overlapping concerns: the commitment to combat racism and legal certainty in sport. The public does not only want tough sanctions, but sanctions that are accountable. When a racial allegation is processed with adequate evidence, confidence in the federation and the competition rises. Conversely, if an allegation is treated as settled without clear scrutiny, space for suspicion and polarisation widens.

The practical impact is also felt in the rhythm of the competition. Foreign players who are central to a team can return to action sooner, so schedules, tactics and club performance are not disrupted by sanctions that are later overturned. For spectators, the decision is a reminder that stadium atmospheres must be protected from discriminatory speech, but that every allegation should not immediately become a social punishment. Clubs, referees and match organising committees have a role in improving reporting mechanisms, including the use of audio, lip-reading and more orderly witness statements. This matters for maintaining a sense of safety.

Going forward, cases like this can become lessons for the national football ecosystem. The federation needs to ensure evidentiary standards and training for match officials become clearer, while clubs and players need to understand the appeal route and public communication that does not pass judgment. In this way, efforts to eradicate racism can run alongside the presumption of innocence.

Tags:BRI Super LeagueKode Disiplin PSSIKomite Banding PSSIMauro CaballeroPSIM Yogyakarta

Related News